• About Us
  • |
  • Contact Us
  • |
  • Login
  • |
  • Subscribe
  • |
  • Todays Weather

U.S. judge upholds NHL defenseman's shortened ban, in defeat for Bettman

Tags : Hockey

A U.S. judge on Wednesday rejected National Hockey League Commissioner Gary Bettman's bid to restore Calgary Flames defenseman Dennis Wideman's 20-game suspension for hitting a linesman, and instead upheld an arbitrator's decision to shorten the ban to 10 games.

U.S. District Judge Alison Nathan in Manhattan said the NHL failed to show that the arbitrator, Georgetown University law professor James Oldham, exceeded his authority under the league's collective bargaining agreement (CBA) with the NHL Players' Association (NHLPA) in halving the suspension.

"Because it is at least arguable that the arbitrator applied the standard of review bargained for in the CBA, the award must be confirmed," Nathan wrote in a 27-page decision.

The NHL, in a statement, said it thought it had met the "very high judicial standard" to void the arbitrator's decision, but was "prepared to turn the page and move on."

Jonathan Weatherdon, a spokesman for the players' union, said the NHLPA was pleased with the decision.

Wideman, who turns 34 on Monday, was suspended for cross-checking linesman Don Henderson in a Jan. 27, 2016 game, with the Nashville Predators, leaving Henderson with a concussion. The defenseman eventually served 19 games of the suspension.

In seeking to restore the original ban, the NHL said Oldham ignored substantial evidence justifying it, and did not act as a "neutral discipline arbitrator" as the CBA required.

But the NHLPA countered that last April's federal appeals court decision restoring New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady's four-game National Football League suspension for deflating footballs showed that courts have only limited authority to review labor arbitration decisions.

Nathan agreed, saying she owed "substantial deference" to Oldham, and that it was "at least arguable" he applied proper deference to Bettman's decision before rejecting it.

"Whether or not his ultimate conclusion was the only reasonable one," Nathan wrote, "the arbitrator's analytical process does not make unambiguously clear that he failed to apply the proper standard of review."

Brady served his four-game suspension, but upon returning led the Patriots on Feb. 5 to a 34-28 victory over the Atlanta Falcons in the Super Bowl.

The case is National Hockey League v National Hockey League Players' Association, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 16-04287.

 


No Comments. Be the first to post comment.


Leave a comment

Football

Messi-less Barca put four past Granada to keep pressure on R...

Barcelona overcame the absence of top scorer Lionel Messi to cut Real Madrid's La Liga lead to two points with a comfort...

Juventus closer to Champions League finals, Monaco lose 2-0

Gonzalo Higuin’s double score helped the Italian Champions Juventus to win over French Monaco by 2-0 and step closer tow...

Barca full-back Aleix Vidal out for five months after disloc...

Barcelona said on Saturday that Vidal underwent a surgery on Saturday night in a hospital in Victoria and will be out o...


Cricket

Ruthless India completed their 3-0 series sweep against Sri ...

Off-spinner Ravichandran Ashwin and paceman Mohammed Shami combined to help India crush Sri Lanka inside three days by a...

Paras Khadka shines in DPL, Team Chauraha selected for a Pla...

Paras Khadka’s brilliant performance has led team Chauraha to be selected for a play-off after beating Rupandehi Challen...

West Indies v England: Ben Stokes says he has grown up befor...

England all-rounder Ben Stokes says he has grown up as his side prepare to start their one-day series against West Indie...


Badminton

TAMANG SIBLINGS WON THE BADMINTON TITLES YESTERDAY

Tamang siblings Ratnajit and Nangshal Devi of Tribhuwan Army club won the singles titles of the Yonex Sunrise Sixth Push...

RATNAJIT TAMANG AND DILMI DIYASH WON THE ANNAPURNA INTERNATI...

Ratnajit Tamang of Nepal and Dilpi Diyash of Sri Lanka won the titles of the Annapurna International Corporate Badminton...

INDIA’S HARINDER PAL SANDHU WINS VICTORIAN OPEN SQUASH CROWN...

: India's Harinder Pal Sandhu continued his fine run by winning a second title in two weeks, beating top-seed Rex Hedric...


Hockey

U.S. judge upholds NHL defenseman's shortened ban, in defeat...

The NHL, in a statement, said it thought it had met the "very high judicial standard" to void the arbitrator's decision,...

Hockey: England beat Germany 5-2 to end tour of South Africa

England's men beat Olympic bronze medallists Germany 5-2 in the final Test of their tour of South Africa.

US beats Russia 7-0 at women's hockey world championships

The Americans scored in bunches Saturday with two goals in less than a minute in the second period and another two in th...


Tennis

Sharapova feels vindicated and empowered after doping ban

Tennis star Maria Sharapova said on Tuesday she is excited about her return to competition next month, feeling vindicate...

Federer beats Nadal in straight sets in Miami Open final

Roger Federer clinched his 91st career title when he beat rival Rafa Nadal 6-3 6-4 in the Miami Open final on Sunday.

“I hope to play for another 2-3 years or more”- Roger Federe...

Federer hasn’t played any matches after re-injuring his surgically repaired left knee at Wimbledon in July last year and...


Golf

Golf: South Korean Kim becomes youngest to win The Players

South Korean Kim Si-woo became the youngest winner of The Players Championship on Sunday when he shot a final round thre...

Confusion over 2020 golf venue date back to bid: report

After the venue was selected to host the tournament in 2012, it received approval from the International Golf Federation...

Golf: Rumford wins first World Super 6 title in final shooto...

It was a sixth European Tour victory for Rumford, who turned professional the year after 17-year-old Phachara was born, ...


Others

2018 Games chief has no doubts about Samsung commitment

Samsung extended its TOP sponsorship contract as a worldwide partner to the Olympics in 2014, taking it through to the T...

Swimming-Olympic great Hackett arrested after 'breakdown'

Hackett won 1,500 meters gold at the 2000 Sydney Olympics and at Athens in 2004 before retiring after the 2008 Games in ...

MANITA SHRESTHA PRADHAN WAS FACILITATED BY SURYA SHRESTHA, J...

Manita Shrestha was honoured by Bal Bikash School on Monday for winning Bronze Medal in the 11th Asian Cadet and 18th As...


Athletics

IAAF World Championships 2017: Sudha Singh's has been name q...

: Indian 3000m steeplechaser Sudha Singh's name has been quietly removed from the list of Indian participants at the Wor...

North Korean delegation arrives in Japan for Winter Asiad

Japan has long had comprehensive sanctions in place against North Korea due to its nuclear tests and ballistic missile l...

Russia to miss the London 2017 IAAF World Championships

Athletes who can follow strict IAAF criteria and show they are clean may be allowed to compete as neutrals and not under...


Volleyball

NDA Has Signed One Year Sponsorship Agreement With Shivam Ce...

New Diamond Academy and Shivam Cement yesterday signed the one-year sponsorship agreement.

NATIONAL WOMEN’S VOLLEYBALL TEAM MEMBER PRATIBHA MALI APPOIN...

Newly -launched sportswear company, Sahas Sports has appointed national women’s volleyball team member Pratibha Mali as ...

First National Men’s Volleyball Tournament to begin from Feb...

According to the spokesperson at National Youth Campaign, the two top teams will receive Rs.350, 000 and Rs. 200,000 res...


Basketball

Knicks' Anthony replaces injured Love for All-Star Game

Anthony, a 10-time All Star, was originally left off the roster for the first time since 2009 but will now participate i...

Nowitzki passes 30,000 point mark to join elite club

"Just an amazing experience," the 19-year veteran said. "After every basket I made, I felt a buzz in the crowd."

Lakers trade guard Williams to Rockets

The Lakers are expected to receive a 2017 first-round draft pick along with forward Corey Brewer in exchange for William...


Races

Intense battle looming as Formula One heads home

Formula One heads home after four opening long-haul races with the championship finely balanced between champions Merced...


Motorsport

Lewis Hamilton dominates Australian Grand Prix practice

Britain's Lewis Hamilton put in a scintillating performance to set the pace in second practice at the season-opening Aus...